Who Said Tyranny Is Defined as That Which Is Legal for the Government but Illegal for the Citizenry - Quant Dynamics
Select Page

Cornell, who is Paul and Diane Gunther`s chair of American history at the school, said the Constitution contains lessons learned at the time of national confederation. He said the Shays rebellion riots had stoked fears among many leaders about mob rule. Jefferson`s quote`s emphasis on fighting government caught the attention of reader David McSwain, a gun owner and Second Amendment supporter from Charlotte, North Carolina. Stites said the Monticello Guardians don`t want to get involved in political debates about gun control, but there is a lot of community interest in real and misattributed quotes from Jefferson, so Jefferson Library researchers provide resources based on searching electronic and physical archives of Jefferson`s writings. He also compared early American militias to a form of taxation, saying citizens had what Jefferson called a “right and duty” to be armed. That is, they had to buy weapons in addition to their goods. Militia membership is often mandatory, Cornell said. A separate page [“Tyranny is defined as what is legal for the government (false quote)”] refers to a number of sources reviewed by Monticello.org historians in March 2009. He concludes: He said the quotes showed that the Second Amendment was intended not only to protect a “vigorous individual right,” but also to serve “as a check against the usurpation of our government.” “I don`t think the mood doesn`t match Jefferson`s thinking, given his other verifiable statements like `a little rebellion from time to time, is a good thing,`” he said. “Yet I think Jefferson would reject the modern far-right belief that an armed rebellion against a socialist and unconstitutional federal government will be necessary in the near future.” When the people fear government, there is tyranny. The main reason people retain the right to own and bear arms is to protect themselves from tyranny within government as a last resort.

Saul Cornell, a professor at Fordham University, said some quotes need to be contextualized, especially those on the “losing side” of debates. He added that he believes both sides of the gun discourse tend to oversimplify the historical intent of the founding fathers. It seems that something that means poverty, disorder and violence every day should be completely avoided, but the desire to conceive children is a natural urge. A quote claiming that Thomas Jefferson said, “Tyranny is defined as that which is legal to the government but illegal to the citizens,” has been circulating on the Internet since at least 2006, probably even earlier. Historians at Jefferson`s official library and website did extensive research to confirm the quote and found that it did not appear anywhere in Jefferson`s writings or quotes. His origin is unknown, but Jefferson has been excluded. “For years, I`ve seen fake quotes about gun issues on the internet,” he said. “Because the founding fathers were so positive about Second Amendment rights, I couldn`t understand why anyone would feel compelled to make up quotes.” This wasn`t new to the internet in August 2019 either, as one of the first results of a research was a 2006 Cato Institute blog post in which the author added Jefferson`s purported comment to his thoughts on internet gambling bans: McSwain said he felt it was necessary to avoid extremist views.

adding that he believed most people had a nuanced perspective on guns. He expressed a desire to define “this rugged boundary between civilian and military weapons.” “Tyranny is defined as what is legal to the government but illegal to the citizens,” is a saying that has been printed in many photos. It has been attributed to the American statesman, diplomat, lawyer, architect, philosopher and founding father Thomas Jefferson (1743-1826), but he never said so. The citation has been cited in print since at least 2005. Monticello.org (a website on Thomas Jefferson) identified the quote as false on March 17, 2009. “Tyranny is what is legal for the government, but illegal for citizens” – without “defined as” – was posted on Twitter by Carey Shenkman on December 30, 2013. “Jefferson: Tyranny is what is legal to government, but illegal to citizens” was posted by Archibald Tuttle on Twitter on August 20, 2014. “Tyranny is what is legal for the government but illegal for citizens” was posted on Twitter by Conspiracybot on December 28, 2021.

Monticello.org tyranny is defined as what is legal for the government (false quote) Quote: “Tyranny is defined as what is legal for the government but illegal for citizens.” (…) Status: This quote was not found in any of Thomas Jefferson`s writings. – Anna Berkes, 17.03.09 Google Groups: provensearchsubmissionsystem business ebay own of johnst…@yahoo.com.sg 20.01.2005, 17:08:53 (…) Tyranny is defined as what is legal for the government but illegal for citizens. – Thomas Jefferson Cato at Liberty JULY 12, 2006 10:01 AM “Tyranny is defined as that which is legal to the government but illegal to the citizens.” By Radley Balko This quote, commonly attributed to Thomas Jefferson, comes to mind when one thinks of yesterday`s congressional vote to ban Internet gambling. Newspapers.com 3. October 2006, The Signal (Santa Clarita, CA), “Defend America! Fire the Republicans” by Bruce McFarland, p. A5, column 2: “Tyranny is defined as that which is lawful to the government but illegal to the citizens.” (Thomas Jefferson). Twitter ⚡ FingerCramp ⚡ @LibertarianMike tyranny is defined as what is legal for the government but illegal for citizens. —Thomas Jefferson 15:10 · 30 March 2009· Twitter Web Client Twitter Carey Shenkman @CareyShenkman @ioerror key presentation to #30c3 “Tyranny is what is legal for the government but illegal for citizens.” youtube.com/watch?v=b0w36GAyZIA 1:39 PM · Dec 30, 2013· Twitter Web Client Twitter Archibald Tuttle @DeadPrecariat Responses to @andThisAndThat @OverAndAround They argue for double standards.

Jefferson: Tyranny is what is legal for the government but illegal for the citizens. 14:47 · 20 August 2014· Twitter Web Client John Stossel@JohnStossel Tyranny is defined as what is legal for the government but illegal for citizens. – Thomas Jefferson 03:30 · 5. June 2016· TweetDeck Twitter Ahmed Baba @AhmedBaba_ Hakeem Jeffries really captures what it all boils down to by quoting Thomas Jefferson: “Tyranny is defined as what is legal to the government but illegal to the citizens.” 17:02 · 30 January 2020· TweetDeck Twitter conspiracy bot @conspiracyb0t Tyranny is what is legal for the government but illegal for citizens. 17:16 · Dec 28, 2021·conspiracyb0t A recent Facebook privacy hoax prompted users to share fake copyright legal language with all their friends. In the words of one worried Facebook poster, “It may have been a hoax, but it didn`t hurt!” The atmosphere of the post-text was important, no matter where it came from. The first reference to the “tyranny in government” quote Berkes has noticed so far is found in a 1989 opinion piece on gun rights by The Orlando Sentinel in Florida. She said the first part of the section of the article that contains the quote, which begins with “No free man shall ever be forbidden to use weapons,” has been verified. But the rest was not in Jefferson`s writings.

Then, more recently, actor Morgan Freeman found himself embroiled in controversy over comments attributed to him about last month`s school shooting in Newtown, Connecticut, that killed 20 children.

Open chat
escríbeme
¡Hola!
¿Cómo te puedo ayudar?